I usually do not pay much attention to cryptocurrencies except when they make a good deal of news. Call me a crypto skeptic: I have never understood the attraction. To begin with, what purpose do they serve?
One of the touted purposes is to eliminate the need for
financial intermediaries and all the concomitant regulation. However, holding
cryptocurrency without the assistance of some kind of intermediary is more than
most people have the time or technical savvy to do. Moreover, the lack of
regulation for trading platforms that are unregulated has given rise to
investors and traders (probably a better term is “gamblers”) losing money due
to scams.
It is hard to determine what crypto really is. Is bitcoin an
asset, even if there is nothing underlying it but clever computer code and a
network of computers? Stablecoins, by contrast, sometimes do have some
underlying assets other than other cryptocurrencies and some sponsoring group
or entity, but it is difficult to determine how trustworthy the backing is. We
can say, though, that one thing crypto is not, and that is money. As taught in
introductory economic classes, money serves three functions: a store of value,
a medium of exchange, and a unit of account. Crypto does none of these things.
While El Salvador has made bitcoin legal tender in that country; this
experiment does not seem to have gone well.
Ben McKenzie, a TV actor in shows I have not watched,
decided during the shutdown of television production during the pandemic to
research and write a book on cryptocurrency. He had the same skepticism I do
about crypto. However, while my inclination is generally not to think about it
too much unless someone asks what I think, McKenzie was much more curious and
decided to research and write a book about it. For assistance he recruited a
journalist from his Brooklyn neighborhood, Jacob Silverman. The book, though,
is written in the first person, with the narrator being McKenzie.
I decided to purchase and read this book after I heard McKenzie
speak about his book on the public radio program Marketplace. I thought
what he had to say was interesting.
The most interesting and readable portions of the book are
the descriptions of the various encounters the authors had with various
denizens of the crypto world. The interviews with Sam Bankman-Friedman, with
whom they talked before and after his financial empire collapsed and indicted for
fraud. It amounts to a fascinating portrayal of a very strange man.
Another episode is an encounter at the 2022 South by
Southwest conference in Austin, Texas. This story seems a bit off. Two men,
claiming they are CIA agents, take McKenzie and Silverman to dinner and,
according to the book, attempt to recruit them as informants on crypto. The
description of this makes the recruitment seem extremely amateurish. It also
leaves questions. What is the CIA doing operating domestically? Doesn’t the CIA
have better ways of learning about crypto than talking to a TV actor and
journalist who are just beginning their research on the topic and are not
players in this market? What was really going on here? If these guys are not
with the CIA, who are they and what do they want? These and similar questions
are not answered, probably because the authors do not know what to think about
what happened. In any case, they got a nice dinner, and the two supposed CIA
agents do not reappear in the book.
The weakest parts of the book are the description of both
the 2008 financial crisis and the 2022 debacles in crypto. They seem to have
been written quickly, there are some typos, and in one place there appear to be
some missing words. This book does not provide a clear account of market
developments or exactly how people were taken advantage of. There are probably
better accounts of the skullduggery that took place elsewhere.
In other words, read this book for a description of the crypto world and an argument for why one should resist any feeling of “FOMO” (fear of missing out). If you are more interested in the technicalities of crypto than I am, you will probably want to go elsewhere.
No comments:
Post a Comment